It was early November outside of New Orleans where I was sat on an airboat skimming across the swamplands at a breakneck speed. There was a dense fog in the air which left the swamp cooler than usual which meant we wouldn’t be seeing many gators. As we skimmed across a small clearing our engine calmed, eventually shutting down, as we finally approached what we all wanted to see, a few alligators. Our guide walked to the front of our small 8-person boat with a nondescript bag full of white things. They were marshmallows we all realized as he began to lob a few into the water surrounding our boat. Sure enough, a few moments later, we had two alligators in our midst, snacking on those marshmallows.
“Gators love them some marshmallows!” our guide quipped. Mesmerized I quickly tried to work out why marshmallows and more importantly who the hell figured this out? “You see, gators are colourblind and they don’t have a sense of smell so anything that’s white and can float they’ll eat! It’s because the bottom of fish are white.” Are you kidding me?!? This is unbelievable. These poor creatures are being sold marshmallows as fish and they have no way of finding out. It’s like the classic fish in a fish bowl argument, they just can’t know any better because it’s beyond their means to do so. This immediately got me thinking about another sales job that’s happening today. To me, it feels a lot like the human version of the gator and the marshmallow. This sales job is the benevolence of technology.
If you pay enough attention you’ll start to see that there is an interesting set of phenomenon emerging out of the increased scale of technological advances we have in our world. These phenomenon are pointing towards a collective of people that are transitioning their beliefs, hopes and salvations from the spiritual into the real, a technological real. Far from a utopia our view of this world view is one that feels totally disempowered from a human perspective, shifting the work that we need to do for our future onto technology. Global warming, geo-engineering. Shitty education, Khan Academy. Corrupt government, social networks. Not enough doctors, quantified self. No church on Sundays, TED videos on Mondays. Like the Gods of years past we are quickly moving towards a fundamentalism of a new kind, the export of responsibility onto technology as a benevolence force.
Why is this happening if it is? It starts with our dogged pursuit to deconstruct and trash anything that is faith in orientation. If there has been one massive casualty in our internet-fuelled information deluge it has been any sort of human-oriented
faith. We swarm faith-oriented value descriptions with a Richard Dawkins like attack of argumentation, hyperlinks, reductionism and condescension that leaves us nothing but technology. As a result the void that is left by the destruction of the spiritual is fulfilled by a new kind of spiritualism that emerges out of the ashes and exists in the form of technologies. Advances in neuroscience, synthetic biology, physics, nano-sciences, genetics, artificial intelligence, robotics and others all point towards hope. And we organize ourselves around this hope. TED conferences, shared videos, new universities promising a tech-enlightened future, news feeds littered with articles about new advances, communities emerging with DIY meetups that aim to re-engineer our biosphere. All are welcome, none are rejected. They place the benevolence of technology at its heart without really understanding how technology functions. It is becoming a marshmallow of the highest order!
Let’s be clear that I am not belittling the work that many people have done with technology. The issue that I am raising is one of concern that without understanding HOW technology functions in our world we will never be able to shape it in a way does help to solve our collective problems. The reality is that technology accelerates our root ideologies. It takes our values and beliefs, expresses them through its means, and shapes itself around them. Two quick examples are the automation of the production process and the digitization of the music industry. Both were instances where we expressed our shared societal values, the first chasing productivity of process the second chasing efficiencies in terms of delivery, and then we scaled and changed our worlds forever, both for the better and the worse. Is technology solely to blame (and take credit) here? Absolutely not. It was our inability to understand its function in expressing and scaling our root values that is. The single most consistent issue we faced at Singularity University with our projects were human issues, ones where there was a lack of shared values. This is where we need time and attention, not on outsourcing hope to a technology to solve our problems.
The prevailing winds in technology circles is that it can do no wrong which, in every sense of the word, just plain wrong. While Silicon Valley luminaries like Peter Thiel will tell you that the their version of education is the way forward, we normal people go about our days in class hoping that someday a technology will figure it all out. Worse yet we watch videos, share links, download apps, e-sign petitions all in hopes that this technology will come and save our souls. The truth is that having spent enough time in the technology-centered swamp most honest people will tell you that we’re all eating a bunch of marshmallows without a real fish anywhere in sight.
Image sourced from: http://now.msn.com/boat-captain-in-florida-gives-gator-a-hand-literally