Image Map

The Internet and our dialectic path to paralysis

When KONY 2012 hit the tubes of the Internet the world was alight with passion, emotion and drive. The reality of becoming a Batman-like justice bearer was closer then ever for millions around the world. The Invisible Children had presented an argument, and associated data and facts, that presented a situation that was fraught with inhumane living conditions, child soldiers and an ill-equipped Ugandan government struggling to deal with a terror like no other. The time to act was now! Armed with our highly polished argument we were asked to channel our Western guilt into action. Just empty out our wallets and petition the shit out of our leaders and collectively we will “capture” Mr. Joseph Kony, the world’s most notorious villain. The message was clear and the purpose was just. Then the Internet took hold.

Conversations about the “truth” of KONY 2012 began to trickle in and the facts and arguments presented by the Invisible Children began to be challenged. An obscure blog post from 2009 surfaced and contrary evidence began to mount. The discourse shifted from an apolitical one surrounding action and justice to an entirely dialectical one, with everyone appropriating THEIR perspectives on the validity of KONY 2012. Instantly, the Internet had replicated the crappy cable news “debates” around KONY but rather than having experts on camera we now had thousands of armchair pundits, myself included, battling for the “truth” through argumentation. But as it always happens lost in the discourse was both the truth and the people involved in the truth.

The reality is that this is not unique to KONY 2012. In fact, as I write this we have a new dialectical process surrounding a censored (or not censored) TED Talk. On almost an hourly basis the conversation grows, new “facts” emerge and the result is an already exhausted populace who barely cares chooses to close their browsers in search of reprieve. You wonder why the Kardashian’s are millionaires?!?

Big data is a challenge in many verticals but arguably none more essential to our survival than the resolution of the dialectical approach to events / issues / topics. Traditionalists will call for a return to true journalism with massive investments in fact checking and proper sourcing. But this loses the ability to give voice to the voiceless through citizen media. Progressives will look to the “unbiased” nature of technology, rank-ordering the discourse in search of truth. The trouble here is that perspectives get lost through this ordering and as big search engines like Google and BING start to incorporate social graphs into their results we end up with an even more narrow view with harsher argumentation and fewer resolutions.

The truth is that we need a solution that resides in the middle. Something that takes the balance and brilliance of old network TV news and adds the participatory media of citizens closest to the events / issues / topics. We never really knew our place in the universe until we saw that photo of our watery earth floating in space. It is this perspective we on the events, issues and topics that dominate our headlines because without it we are on a path towards gridlock with an Internet that looks for truth entirely through opinion.

Image from Wikipedia

Don’t tweet this without reading it.

We’ve all been there. We’re “surfing the web” looking for things to read, and it hits us. We see a story link, a tweet, or perhaps something that pops up on Facebook that makes us click. It’s not because the topic is of any particular relevance to us, it’s because the story lets us vilify… Continue Reading

Is it time to change the way we work?

This is the letter that Apple gives to employees on their first day. You might call it ‘company culture’, but it surely makes you think about business organizations as groups of people, and how important some values are for them to prosper and generate value. For themselves and their community. We are seeing some organization… Continue Reading

Curating Needles in the Haystacks of the Internet

If the authors of this blog are lucky, someone on the internet has recommended this post to you. One might say, we hope it was curated amongst the other 500,000 wordpress blog posts each day. The topic of web curation has been explored extensively in the past year, and as social networks and applications continue… Continue Reading

Can technology replace consumerism in the 21st Century?

It’s hard to consume any kind of media and not identify some form of rejection of consumerism. Global capitalism, for all its virtues, has propelled our world into a direction that has seemingly far more casualties than it does benefactors.  One needs only to turn to the global ecological crisis or the debt nightmare in… Continue Reading

Modern Storytelling: Enhanced or Spawned by Technology?

Len: This panel-style blog post was spawned by my recent interest in the game Zombies, Run! As someone who is passionate about the Zombie genre, but not at all passionate about exercise, I was excited to find a fusion of mobile technology, storytelling, and real-world activity that would help gamify my healthy habits. I’ll let the video… Continue Reading

Does digital help resurrect analog?

The following is a Q&A that explores the reoccurrence of analog and obsolete technology within our highly-connected present day. It was inspired by Rick Liebling’s latest explorations of this topic. 1)Francesca: As digital kicks in and everything becomes convergent, there is also a big comeback of analog products like vinyl, radio devices, .., and yes typewriters. How… Continue Reading

Can the internet save Europe?

A few days ago the EU tasked Openideo with a challenge aimed to develop the best possible program to support digital startups: “How might we support web entrepreneurs in launching and growing sustainable global businesses?” Maybe it’s because I am EU citizen but I have found it very interesting (and I am participating) because I… Continue Reading

Wired Poverty, Fighting Dystopia and Homeless Hotspots

Homeless Hotspots was a program developed by BBH Labs to help homeless individuals earn an income during the South by Southwest conference. By providing a wi-fi signal to hordes of connection seekers nearby (by literally carrying a mobile hotspot on their back) in crowded areas, members of the HH team were able to earn donations… Continue Reading

The time for Lulz is over

As most have seen in the past day or so many key figures within the groups Anonymous and LulzSec have been arrested and face multiple decades of incarceration. This critical blow to the Internet-based vigilante group devastates the very infrastructure of activity that has, to date, kept a critical check on secrecy, exploitation and manipulation… Continue Reading